java - Different Encoders Provided Different Encoded Values -

pardon me! weak in java.

i referring stackoverflow post: digital signature creation , verification. added base64 encoders of bouncy castle , apache. return differemt strings ([b@a470b8,[b@1e4457d,[b@10b4b2f, [b@750159..). "sun.misc.base64encoder" returns encoded. but, restricted. please advise how use bouncy castle base64 or apache bas64 classes. in advance!

my code , results follows:

package abc;  import java.io.fileinputstream;<br> import java.security.key;<br> import java.security.keystore;<br> import java.security.privatekey;<br> import java.security.security;<br> import java.security.signature;<br> import java.security.cert.x509certificate;<br> import java.util.arraylist;<br> import java.util.list;<br> import org.apache.pdfbox.pdfwriter.coswriter;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cert.jcajce.jcacertstore;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cms.cmsprocessablebytearray;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cms.cmssigneddata;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cms.cmssigneddatagenerator;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cms.cmstypeddata;<br> import org.bouncycastle.cms.jcajce.jcasignerinfogeneratorbuilder;<br> import org.bouncycastle.jce.provider.bouncycastleprovider;<br> import org.bouncycastle.operator.contentsigner;<br> import org.bouncycastle.operator.jcajce.jcacontentsignerbuilder;<br> import org.bouncycastle.operator.jcajce.jcadigestcalculatorproviderbuilder;<br> import org.bouncycastle.util.store;<br> import sun.misc.base64encoder;<br>  public class generatesignature { public static void main(string[] args) throws exception {     string keystore_file = "resources/my.p12";     string keystore_instance = "pkcs12";     string keystore_pwd = "password";     string keystore_alias = "signcert";     string text = "this message";      security.addprovider(new bouncycastleprovider());     keystore ks = keystore.getinstance(keystore_instance);     ks.load(new fileinputstream(keystore_file), keystore_pwd.tochararray());     key key = ks.getkey(keystore_alias, keystore_pwd.tochararray());     //sign     privatekey privkey = (privatekey) key;     signature signature = signature.getinstance("sha1withrsa", "bc");     signature.initsign(privkey);     signature.update(text.getbytes());      //build cms     x509certificate cert = (x509certificate) ks.getcertificate(keystore_alias);     list certlist = new arraylist();     cmstypeddata msg = new cmsprocessablebytearray(signature.sign());     certlist.add(cert);     store certs = new jcacertstore(certlist);     cmssigneddatagenerator gen = new cmssigneddatagenerator();     contentsigner sha1signer = new jcacontentsignerbuilder("sha1withrsa").setprovider("bc").build(privkey);     gen.addsignerinfogenerator(new jcasignerinfogeneratorbuilder(new jcadigestcalculatorproviderbuilder().setprovider("bc").build()).build(sha1signer, cert));     gen.addcertificates(certs);     cmssigneddata sigdata = gen.generate(msg, false);      base64encoder encoder = new base64encoder();      system.out.println("================start : signed content using sun base64encoder=================================================================================");     string signedcontent = encoder.encode((byte[]) sigdata.getsignedcontent().getcontent());     system.out.println("signed content: " + signedcontent.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed content using sun base64encoder=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("================start : signed encoded content using sun base64encoder=================================================================================");     string envelopeddata = encoder.encode(sigdata.getencoded());     system.out.println("enveloped data: " + envelopeddata.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed encoded content using sun base64encoder=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("");      //base64 bcencoderdecoder = new base64();     system.out.println("================start : signed content using bouncy castle base64=================================================================================");     byte[] bcsignedcontent = org.bouncycastle.util.encoders.base64.encode((byte[]) sigdata.getsignedcontent().getcontent());     system.out.println("signed content: " + bcsignedcontent.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed content using bouncy castle base64=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("================start : signed encoded content using bouncy castle base64=================================================================================");     byte[] bcenvelopeddata = org.bouncycastle.util.encoders.base64.encode(sigdata.getencoded());     system.out.println("enveloped data: " + bcenvelopeddata.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed encoded content using bouncy castle base64=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("");      //base64 apencoderdecoder = new base64();     system.out.println("================start : signed content using apache base64=================================================================================");     byte[] apsignedcontent = org.apache.commons.codec.binary.base64.encodebase64((byte[]) sigdata.getsignedcontent().getcontent());     system.out.println("signed content: " + apsignedcontent.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed content using apache base64=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("================start : signed encoded content using apache base64=================================================================================");     byte[] apenvelopeddata = org.apache.commons.codec.binary.base64.encodebase64(sigdata.getencoded());     system.out.println("enveloped data: " + apenvelopeddata.tostring());     system.out.println("================end : signed encoded content using apache base64=================================================================================");     system.out.println("");     system.out.println("");  } 

}

output ================sun base64encoder========================================================= signed content:     se4jkzurehmsfxmu3ffb7+bke17g15ckb9ioonyj7efphuvoibd8j/wsydvbdtx0plwjssnhlfe6 bzcmhzvebgju8l7rnkbh9cebt3x6lqpfvvup16topnngidffa4ge97ja2+dco5vtiz15ltv6nit8 ktgfjgscyglkbxgowok=  enveloped data: miagcsqgsib3dqehaqcamiacaqexczajbgurdgmcgguamiagcsqgsib3dqehaqaaoiawgggumih+ oamcaqicbgfekafvudanbgkqhkig9w0baqqfadaomqwwcgydvqqdewntqkkwhhcnmtqwmza0mdk1 mtq2whcnmtywmza0mdk1mtq2wjaomqwwcgydvqqdewntqkkwgz8wdqyjkozihvcnaqebbqadgy0a migjaogbamabj6hoxls1fwrimskdcreyqj3lds773c0bg4n5tom+5r57vkm9lbkcq9xrnzsjzcxt ohe6wlths/xrptgymkwlrgavc47ptgweaowlwzvm6zwys8lgtafqr1jsvscjoth02y1ggduebzb3 wmjmrbw/5nt3ktna3ugpgsa5f/8zagmbaaewdqyjkozihvcnaqeebqadgyeaxuauotxzt4czgd0k fyt/b0qhtq6pqnag9slsksfbqpsidxrrkkkdbbxh33rkdh0t0xqtwn8/2rvalorqnyablse6krpr 4/dm+swcgwgnk8/gwifzbjjyv76iagu5+cbik/m1omsy/7rwjgm6nms3nnvy7vghymususvpa3ix c2saadgcar0wggezagebmbgwdjemmaoga1ueaxmdu0jjagybrjgn77gwcqyfkw4dahofakbdmbgg csqgsib3dqejazelbgkqhkig9w0bbwewhayjkozihvcnaqkfmq8xdte0mdmwnjexntexovowiwyj kozihvcnaqkemryefavetwus6kyobos2ovzmvsa9xpplma0gcsqgsib3dqebaquabigaugvdfkvr 7/qsgpdsjeos3a0u0uqjalv01idcrhsa1sd23qyjaxbednhajhz6ymyi0vu5wlkily3nrwpajmvq itix/wro+qeqbaxk5sityhjssghyki0ccvix0skovebd9yjox0eeijitb57lr42kanhdxyeaji9o yy2ipyn8wu8aaaaaaaa= ================end :sun base64encoder results ==========================================  ================start : bouncy castle base64 encoding ===================================== signed content: [b@a470b8<br> enveloped data: [b@1e4457d<br> ================end : bouncy castle base64 encoding =====================================  ================start : apache base64 encoding ===================================== signed content: [b@10b4b2f enveloped data: [b@750159 ================end : apache base64 encoding ===================================== 

the base64 encoders of bouncy castle , apache return encoded data (even though consist of ascii characters) byte arrays (which know, after have used byte[] type these information).

if want output contents in readable form, should not xxx.tostring() (because result in [b@a470b8,[b@1e4457d,[b@10b4b2f, [b@750159, i.e. type identifier [b , memory address) instead new string(xxx), e.g. instead of

system.out.println("signed content: " + bcsignedcontent.tostring()); 

use

system.out.println("signed content: " + new string(bcsignedcontent));